Appraiser Identity Theft

In the wake of a recent warning from Fannie Mae highlighting a surge in deceptive appraisals, it's time to shine a spotlight on an issue that has flown under the radar. In January, Fannie Mae's Mortgage Fraud Investigations team (MFI) disclosed a concerning trend— a "significant number" of loans feature completed appraisals that exploit the identities of actively licensed appraisers.

According to Fannie Mae, this misuse of appraiser identities occurred between 2021 and 2023. Notably, there's no indication that the real appraisers, whose identities were hijacked, were aware of this unauthorized use of their credentials. This revelation poses a potential threat to the integrity of the mortgage process, prompting a reassessment of current security measures.

In response to this alarming development, Fannie Mae and us here at the Knowledge Coop emphasize the need for heightened scrutiny when dealing with third-party vendors and appraisals. Thorough vetting is paramount, urging industry professionals to verify information through public records and other available documents to ensure the authenticity of appraiser identities and the accuracy of the appraisal process.

Fannie Mae has established a valuable resource for industry professionals to report suspected cases of this fraudulent activity. If you suspect any foul play related to appraisals, you can submit details through the Fannie Mae Mortgage Fraud Prevention Website. This collective effort is vital to upholding the integrity of the mortgage industry and preventing fraudulent practices that erode the trust and reliability of the appraisal process.

As the mortgage industry navigates unforeseen challenges, staying informed and vigilant is more critical than ever. Fannie Mae's alert on bogus appraisals serves as a stark reminder of the need for proactive measures to combat fraud. By adhering to the recommendations of thorough vetting and promptly reporting suspicions, industry professionals can collectively contribute to a more secure and resilient mortgage ecosystem. Diligence is not just a professional responsibility; it's a safeguard for the trust and confidence of homeowners and stakeholders alike in the face of evolving threats.